eltehelado

Chinese Mandarin :Chinese Mandarin Level
Registered on : 2007-10-19
Language : None
Posts : 2
Responses : 0
Comments : 0

From :   Not Applicable

Date : 2007-10-20 / 02:03AM

I know that when “ma” is added to the end of a sentence, it makes it a question. As in Ni hao ma? But why don’t you need it to say Ni yao shenme?

Views (1095)   Replies (4)  

Latest Responses

Pooshybooshy

Chinese Mandarin :Chinese Mandarin Level
Registered on : 2007-10-09
Language : None
Posts : 12
Responses : 28
Comments : 44
 Pooshybooshy hotmail.com 
2007-10-20 / 02:54AM

I only know the basics, but I think it might just be because that sentence can only be put as a question anyway. I mean, you can say “ni hao” to say hello, but you need to add “ma” if it is a question so people know it is a question. So ma is used when you say something that can be put as either a question or a statement. In this case, “what do you want” is only used as a question, so you don’t need ‘ma’ to signify it is a question, because you can’t say “what do you want” without it being a question.

Reply  
Pooshybooshy

Chinese Mandarin :Chinese Mandarin Level
Registered on : 2007-10-09
Language : None
Posts : 12
Responses : 28
Comments : 44
 Pooshybooshy hotmail.com 
2007-10-20 / 02:57AM

Hope that helps. Sorry if it is confusing. I basically mean that ‘ma’ is added to something that can be either a statement or a question – so if ma is added you know they are asking and not stating. But “what do you want” is only used as a question, so you don’t need ma to show that it is.

Reply  
managerchloe

Chinese Mandarin :Chinese Mandarin Level
Registered on : 2007-07-25
Language : None
Posts : 0
Responses : 24
Comments : 0
 Miss. Tone bennysland.com 
2007-10-20 / 09:34AM

Ni hao Skylar! I don’t need give you answer now. Pooshybooshy is absolutely correct! Xie xie ni Pooshyboosy!

Yes, ‘ni yao shen me?’ is already a question, so you don’t need ‘ma’ any more.

Another example:

ta shi lao shi = he’s a teacher (this is a statement)

but let’s add ‘ma’

ta shi la shi ma? = is he a teacher? (now it’s a question!)

‘shen me’ means ‘what’. It already indicates it’s a question. You don’t need add ‘ma’.

Reply  
managerbenny

Chinese Mandarin :Chinese Mandarin Level
Registered on : 2007-07-25
Language : None
Posts : 2
Responses : 428
Comments : 0
 Benny bennysland.com 
2007-10-20 / 09:40AM

Impressive! Pooshybooshy. You might be one of Bennysland’s Angel in the future!

Reply  

Membership

Enjoy all the learning features & content by upgrading your membership to a Royal Member.

Make Me A
ROYAL MEMBER

AskBenny
Every Brick Counts

Donate to help build a better Chinese learning site

Spread the word and share the love of Chinese Language Learning!
Follow askbenny on Twitter